Old, wet or contaminated insulation
Insulation Removal & Replacement in Brooklyn, NY
Out with what is ruined, a clean surface to seal, and new insulation that suits the space.
- Free on-site estimates anywhere in Brooklyn
- Written quote naming foam type, thickness and R-value for each area
- Leaks, damp masonry and old wiring flagged before anything is covered
When Old Insulation Has to Go
Insulation removal and replacement makes sense when what is there is doing more harm than good. In Brooklyn we see three common reasons: insulation soaked by roof leaks or flooding, insulation fouled by mice, rats or pigeons in cocklofts and cellars, and old material that blocks the air sealing a house needs. We remove it, clean up, seal what was hidden underneath, and install the replacement.
Flood-soaked insulation
Hurricane Sandy on October 29, 2012 pushed water deep into the neighborhoods along Jamaica Bay and the south shore. The National Weather Service's impact summary for the Rockaway Inlet gauge lists Gerritsen Beach, Bergen Beach, Mill Basin and Canarsie among the hardest hit areas, with flooding reaching inland past Avenue X into Bensonhurst, Gravesend and Sheepshead Bay. Fiberglass batts that have been under floodwater hold moisture and contamination and need to come out. When we replace them in a flood-prone house, we usually recommend closed-cell foam, which takes on very little water.
Pests and debris
Cocklofts and cellars are where rodents and birds nest. Insulation full of droppings, nesting material and urine smells and can affect air quality in the rooms below. We remove it with HEPA vacuums or by hand, bag it, and clean the space before anything new goes in. If there are entry points, we point them out so they can be closed.
Removing old spray foam
Foam that was installed badly, cured wrong, or sprayed over a leak sometimes has to come out. It is slow work, done by cutting and scraping. Fixr lists spray foam removal at $1.50 to $3 per square foot and up to about $5 when it has to be hand-chipped, and HomeGuide lists $1.00 to $2.50.
Asbestos and vermiculite
Some older Brooklyn houses have vermiculite loose fill or pipe and boiler insulation that may contain asbestos. We do not disturb suspect material. If we see it, we stop and recommend testing, and any abatement is handled by a licensed abatement contractor before we do our part. HomeAdvisor lists asbestos removal at $1,190 to $3,255 as a national range.
Replacement
Once the space is clear, we seal the air leaks that were hidden, and then install the right material: closed-cell foam, open-cell foam, or blown-in, depending on the space and the moisture risk.
Tell us what you found and where. We will look and send a written price for removal and replacement. Get a free estimate
What Removal Covers
The removal jobs we handle most often.
Flood-damaged insulation
Wet batts and loose fill taken out of cellars, crawl spaces and lower walls.
Pest-contaminated insulation
Insulation fouled by rodents or birds, removed and the space cleaned.
Old loose fill and batts
Compressed, dusty or patchy insulation removed so the ceiling can be sealed properly.
Failed spray foam
Foam that was installed badly or over a leak, cut and scraped out.
Replacement insulation
New foam or blown-in installed after sealing.

Published Insulation Removal Costs
| Job | Range and source |
|---|---|
| Insulation removal, per sq ft | $1 to $2 (HomeAdvisor) |
| Typical removal job | $600 to $1,200, about $900 average (HomeAdvisor) |
| About 1,000 sq ft | $1,000 to $2,000 (HomeAdvisor) |
| Removal plus replacement | About $1,852 average (HomeAdvisor) |
| Spray foam removal | $1.00 to $2.50 per sq ft (HomeGuide); $1.50 to $3, up to about $5 hand-chipped (Fixr) |
| Asbestos removal (abatement contractor) | $1,190 to $3,255 (HomeAdvisor) |
National figures from HomeAdvisor (June 2026), HomeGuide (2026) and Fixr (2025). Amount of material, access, contamination and disposal drive the cost. We price your job on a written estimate, and that estimate is what you pay.
How Removal and Replacement Runs
1. Inspect
We look at the material, its condition, the access and any suspect asbestos or vermiculite.
2. Quote
Removal, cleanup, sealing and replacement are priced separately in writing.
3. Remove and clean
We contain the area, remove the old material and clean the space.
4. Seal and replace
We seal the leaks we uncovered and install the new insulation.

Why Choose Us for Insulation Removal & Replacement
We stop at suspect material
Vermiculite or possible asbestos gets tested before anyone disturbs it.
Line-item pricing
Removal and replacement are priced separately so you can see each part.
Insulation Removal & Replacement Questions
Does insulation have to come out after a flood?
Fiberglass and cellulose that have been under floodwater hold moisture and contamination and generally should be removed. Closed-cell foam takes on very little water and often can stay if it is intact and the wall behind it can dry.
Can new insulation go over old insulation?
If the old material is dry and clean, often yes. If it is wet, moldy, or full of droppings, it should come out first.
What if you find asbestos?
We stop and recommend testing. Abatement is handled by a licensed abatement contractor before we continue.
How long does removal take?
Most cockloft or cellar removals take a day or two, depending on access and the amount of material. We give you a schedule with the quote.

Insulation Removal & Replacement Service Areas
- Spray Foam Insulation in Brooklyn, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Park Slope, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Brooklyn Heights, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Williamsburg, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Greenpoint, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Bushwick, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Bedford–Stuyvesant, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Crown Heights, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Flatbush, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Ditmas Park, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Midwood, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Sunset Park, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Bay Ridge, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Dyker Heights, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Bensonhurst, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Sheepshead Bay, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Gerritsen Beach, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Canarsie, NY
- Spray Foam Insulation in Red Hook, NY
Get an Insulation Removal & Replacement Estimate
Tell us what you found. We will inspect it and send a written price for removal and replacement.